Against intellectual monopoly david levines economic and. Boldrin argues that and patent are used by the politically powerful to maintain monopoly profits. All economists, lawyers, judges, and policymakers should read this book. Michele boldrin is an italian economist and author whose research interests include business cycle fluctuations, economic growth, technological progress and intellectual property.
In their recent book, against intellectual monopoly, michele boldrin and david. In their recent book, against intellectual monopoly, michele b. A world without intellectual property boldrin and levine. Published in volume 49, issue 2, pages 422 of journal of economic literature, june 2011, abstract. They believe the current patent system discourages and prevents inventions from entering the marketplace. Levine intellectual property patents and s have become controversial. Against intellectual monopoly socalled intellectual property is in fact an intellectual monopoly that hinders rather than michele boldrin and david k. Many small unpredictable incidents or small differences in initial circumstances can lead to either inclusive or exclusive institutions or more broadly success or failure. Several writers, stephan kinsella most notably among them, have argued that patents and s should not form part of a proper libertarian law.
We witness teenagers being sued for pirating music and we observe aids patients in africa dying due to lack of ability to pay for drugs that are high priced to satisfy patent holders. This is one such book, and it is destined to be a classic in the economics. Boldrin and levine say abolition is the best option. Levine write, intellectual property law is not about your right to control your copy of your idea this is a right that we have just pointed out, does not need a great deal of protection. Aug 03, 2019 against intellectual monopoly socalled intellectual property is in fact an intellectual monopoly that hinders rather than michele boldrin and david k.
Acemoglu and robinsons why nations fail 2012 is a grand history in the style of diamond 1997 or mcneil 1963. Asset pricing lessons for modeling business cycles by michele boldrin book 23 editions published between 1995 and 1996 in english and held by 170 worldcat member libraries worldwide. Boldrin and levine 2005 and llanes and trento 2009 have explored the theory, many casestudies involving patents and other fractionated ownership problems can be found in heller 2008 a second widely cited benefit of patent systems although not so much in the economics literature is the notion that patents are a. Mar 05, 2009 boldrin and levine promote a drastic reform of the patent system in their book. The one think you cannot do is saying that you have written the book, instead of boldrin and levine. Such is the case with against intellectual monopoly cambridge university press, 2008 by michele boldrin and david levine, two daring professors of economics at washington university in st. Dont assume anyone who doesnt favor ip is a propertyhating socialist. Michele boldrin and david levine, two wellknown economists, argue that.
Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Boldrin and levine promote a drastic reform of the patent system in their book. I am not finished with it yet but it is so strange, powerful and complex that i will talk about it in two parts. Michele boldrin is the author of against intellectual monopoly 4. He argues that the incentive effects that have been used to justify. Such is the case with against intellectual monopoly by michele boldrin and david levine, two daring professors of economics at washington university in st. Michele boldrin author of against intellectual monopoly. They propose the law should be restored to match the intent of the u. Against intellectual monopoly michele boldrin, david k. Against intellectual monopoly by michele boldrin goodreads. Boldrin and levine 2008 argue that the traditional view according to which for. In their recent book, against intellectual monopoly, michele boldrin and david levine conclude that patents and s are not necessary to provide protection for either innovation or creative expression and should be eliminated. Like those books, this book is exceptionally fun to read and full of interesting historical examples and provocative ideas.
Against intellectual monopoly, by michele boldrin and david levine, is a coherent, wellwritten, and persuasive argument against strong forms of government protection of intellectual property rights. This book has broad coverage of both s and patents and is designed. Boldrin and levine dont deny this, but they show that this isnt the full story. Jul 07, 2008 this book has broad coverage of both s and patents and is designed for a general audience, focusing on simple examples. Michele boldrin was born in padova, italy, in 1956. The authors contend that intellectual property rights do not generally promote social welfare, that intellectual property protection generates perverse distributional outcomes, and that firms do. It is also posted on their site with the permission of the publisher. Boldrin and levine hold a lot of creative work inspired by selfactualization and firstmover advantages. As the title implies, they characterize all ip as a stategranted monopoly, which can be criticized on both moral and utilitarian grounds. Michele boldrin and david levine are two wellknown economists who recently published against intellectual monopoly, which is a part of our techdirt book. He and levine are known for opposing the 2009 us stimulus bill. Against intellectual monopoly mises store mises institute. Economists say copyright and patent laws are killing.
Levine see innovation as a key to reviving the economy. In it, they challenge conventional wisdom about patents and argue that we would be better off without them. Posts about michael boldrin written by nicholasamiller. Many people argue that the patent system has gone wrong in recent years, boldrin and levine argue that the. Published in volume 27, issue 1, pages 322 of journal of economic perspectives, winter 20, abstract. Essentially they advocate for completely wiping the slate clean and getting rid of all intellectual property. Boldrin and levine, highly respected economic theorists, have produced a lively and readable book for the intelligent layman. Jul 27, 2009 michele boldrin and david levine are two wellknown economists who recently published against intellectual monopoly, which is a part of our techdirt book club which gives you against monopoly.
In this respect, they share the good company of thomas jefferson, who. Michele boldrin and david levine, on the other hand, boldly declare in their recent work against intellectual monopoly that they have arrived at. The case against patents american economic association. This book has broad coverage of both s and patents and is designed for a general audience, focusing on simple examples. Boldrin and levine s book, the story s value as a source of reliable inferences concerning the general merits and shortcomings of the patent system is open to doubt. Louis talks with econtalk host russ roberts about intellectual property and boldrin s book, cowritten with david levine, against intellectual monopoly. They illustrate their claim through a discussion of james watt, whose patents on the steam engine restricted innovation. Levine the following is an excerpt from the full paper by michele boldrin and david k. Rarely does a book come along that prompts a wholesale revision in the way we perceive laws and legislation, social progress, and the very foundations of development economics. Louis talks with econtalk host russ roberts about intellectual property and boldrins book, cowritten with david levine, against intellectual monopoly. David k levine a primer on ugaritic is an introduction to the language of the ancient city of ugarit, a city that flourished in the second millennium bce on the lebanese coast, placed in the context of the. If you do, check out boldrin and levine s book on the practical case against ip, and stephan kinsellas on the theoretical case.
Against intellectual monopoly david levines economic. With piracy and struggles over intellectual property in the news daily, it is time to wonder about this issue, its relationship to freedom, property rights, and efficiency. Biggs distinguished professor of economics at washington university in st. Against intellectual monopoly industrial economics cambridge. The two sides of the contemporary debate over intellectual property agree that the law needs to strike a balance between providing sufficient incentive for creation and the freedom to make use of existing ideas. Last october i published a post about the article the case against patents by michele boldrin and david k. Economist michele boldrin biography, theories and books. Socalled intellectual property is in fact an intellectual monopoly that hinders for the lawrence r. He moved to mestrevenezia at the age of ten, where he attended the liceo giordano bruno and the universita ca foscari, graduating magna cum laude in economics in july 1982. Aug 12, 2008 against intellectual monopoly is a relentless, pounding, take no prisoners attack on patent and law.
Along with his colleague and coauthor david levine, he was part of the. They have written a book that is likely to rock your world, as it has mine. They challenge the notion of the individual creator working for all hours of the night to solve a big problem with financial incentives at the forefront of his or her mind. The authors conclude that the only sensible policy to follow is to eliminate the patents and systems as they currently exist. Jun 14, 2019 against intellectual monopoly socalled intellectual property is in fact an intellectual monopoly that hinders rather than michele boldrin and david k. Brock, university of wisconsin, madison boldrin and levine, highly respected economic theorists, have produced a lively and readable book for the intelligent layman. Levine conclude that patents and s are not necessary to provide protection for either innovation or creative expression and should be eliminated. In their recent book, against intellectual monopoly, michele boldrin and david levine conclude that patents and s. Boldrin and levine have dramatically increased that burden for those who enjoy intellectual monopoly. In their recent book, against intellectual monopoly, michele boldrin and david levine conclude that patents and s are not necessary to provide.
Ive been taking a break from my regularly scheduled program of reading books designed to make me a lean, mean law student machine and have been digesting michael boldrin and david k. The case against patents by michele boldrin and david k. Boldrin and levine argue that a great deal of technological innovation, from chemicals to cars, from radio and tv to personal computers, has historically taken place in young industries with. Jul 07, 2008 last october i published a post about the article the case against patents by michele boldrin and david k. The book will open a fresh debate on the policy on intellectual property protection. It joins lessigs free culture and hellers the gridlock economy as an instant classic and a mustread on these issues. The case against patents can be summarized briefly. One of the strengths of the book is its emphasis on the intrinsic randomness of history. Boldrin and levine are coauthors of the book against intellectual monopoly cambridge university press, 2008.
What intellectual property law is really about is about your right to control my. This is one such book, and it is destined to be a classic in the economics literature. Louis, with research specialties in game theory and general equilibrium theory. Cambridge core industrial economics against intellectual monopoly by michele michele boldrin, university of minnesota, david k. Against intellectual monopoly by michele boldrin, david k. I had mentioned at the end that there was also a book, entitled against intellectual monopoly. Even if an inventor benefits from a patent, his monopoly position restricts the ability of other inventors to modify and improve his product. Against intellectual monopoly, by michele boldrin mises. Think about your instinctual position on the issue and ask yourself what worldview it comes from. He currently teaches at washington university in st. May 18, 2009 michele boldrin of washington university in st. One of the most important recent advances in libertarian theory has come in the field of intellectual property. That is plagiarism and boldrin and levine are against it but probably wont sue you. Boldrin and levines book, the story s value as a source of reliable inferences concerning the general merits and shortcomings of the patent system is open to doubt.
489 311 951 55 202 803 312 1461 916 1413 706 1291 1126 613 626 1369 649 343 139 102 1079 989 343 671 1529 922 228 649 459 814 620 563 118 1062 41 949 375 928 955 779 63